The Thrill of the Genealogy Hunt – Let a Record Click Expert Review Be Your Guide

The results are in for our Strategy Saturday call-out!. We unleashed one of our Accredited Genealogists on a brickwall case, and now we share the results with you. Put on your pith helmet . . . we’re entering the genealogy jungle.

What makes Record Click unique from other genealogy research firms is our understanding that the “hunt” is part of the thrill of a genealogy “find.” While Record Click offers full genealogy research services, some of our clients, upon hitting a brick wall, just need a new strategy to get them back on track. That’s why Record Click offers its warrior genealogists a different kind of service with its Strategy Session plan. Next time you hit an impasse, let Record Click pair you up with one of our professional lineage researchers, who will review your case, and offer you alternative, concrete ways to reach your goal. If it can be found, our researchers will help you find it.

Record Click posted a call-out in July for brickwall cases to be submitted by our readers. Of the many great submissions we received, our staff selected a case sent in by JP, an avid genealogist from Austin, Texas. JP had mapped her ancestry to a 3rd great grandfather, Uriah Frazier, but was stymied in verifying Uriah’s father, who was believed to be William Frazier. One of JP’s relatives had engaged the services of Brent Holcomb, a well-known professional researcher and prolific author of Southern history. Mr. Holcomb located documents involving the two Frazier men and wrote about the family in one of his many books. Unfortunately, JP’s relative misplaced Holcomb’s report, and JP had no clue how to relocate the information, short of contacting Brent Holcomb and starting all over again.

Record Click selected one of its Accredited Genealogists (AG) based in Salt Lake City to perform the Expert Review for JP’s query. Our AG went to the Family History Library and began her search by combing through Brent Holcomb’s books – a “time consuming search” in her words – focusing primarily on his research of the Lexington-Fairfield-Orangeburgh areas in South Carolina.

JP’s relative was under the assumption that after the death of William Frazier, his children (including Uriah) sued their stepmother, Catharine Frazier, the William’s widow. While there was indeed a lawsuit in 1840, Record Click’s AG discovered in “Some South Carolina County Records – Vol 1” compiled by Brent Holcomb in 1976, that the facts were different from those relayed by JP’s relative. It turns out Catharine Frazier, after the death of her husband William, filed a petition in November 1840 in the Court of Ordinary for Lexington District against her husband’s children, including Uriah and his siblings. It seems William Frazier had died intestate and left a tract of land, which the Court decreed be sold in public sale, and which was purchased by Catharine Frazier.

From the information found in Brent Holcomb’s book (which was clearly noted for source), JP contacted the State Archives of South Carolina and asked about acquiring a copy of the record. The archivist referred to the Lexington County Courthouse fires, stating that only scattered records were available for pre-1839; however, JP pursued it, explaining that Brent Holcomb had written about the case in a 1976 publication. She shared the source information listed in the Expert Review, and that was the clue the archivist needed to know that the information was contained in the Lexington County Deed Book, which he located. He is sending a copy of Catharine Frazier’s petition to JP.

Now, we play the waiting game. Will the record identify Catharine’s husband as William? If so, JP will have solved the mystery: “Who is Uriah’s father?” If not, then it’s back to the drawing board. We will be updating you all as this genealogy research project unfolds. In the meantime, Record Click’s AG offered additional verification to JP in regard to Uriah’s siblings and their spouse’s names, all of which is important to expanding the family’s pedigree.

Don’t miss out on Record Click’s insightful interview with Brent Holcomb.

To hire an professional genealogist for your expert genealogy analysis, contact us.


  • Hi Elizabeth and all of Record Click,

    I just wanted to let you know how much I appreciate the favor you and Joyce (an Accredited Genealogist at Record Click) have shown me. I had heard that a “lawsuit” existed concerning my great great grandfather, and I realized it could be a link that I needed to trace my family. However, when I would ask county clerks, I was always met with the excuse that nothing existed after the burning of courthouses in the South, especially Lexington County, South Carolina! How surprised I was when I used the reference to Brent Holcomb’s book, which Joyce provided in her review, the Archivist at the South Carolina State Archives agreed to check the Equity Records. He found the petition in the Lexington County Deed Book, and I have ordered a copy. Can’t wait to get my hands on it!

    Thank you so much for the expert guidance that Record Click offered me in this very difficult genealogy research brickwall. I’ll keep you posted.

    Austin, TX

    • JP, I am just thrilled that our Expert Review was indeed able to shift your genealogy wall a little. We are of course very excited to hear how the hunt finally turns out, so keep us posted!

    • JP,
      I too am looking for William Frazier verification as Uriah’s father and his ancestors. He is my brick wall too!! Uriah’s son James Patrick is my great grandfather.

  • Thank you for the nice mention. I am glad that my information was helpful. I publish a quarterly magazine, The South Carolina Magazine of Ancestral Research. Issues area published and mailed in February, May, August, and November. The usual subscription is $30.00, but I will make a special offer to anyone seeing this blog of $25.00 for the 2012 issues. See on my webpage:

    • My goodness Brent it is you! How wonderful to hear from you, and what a nice surprise. Yes, we will certainly let our readers know about this. We will also mention it on our Facebook page!

      Thank you so much. Elizabeth

Leave a Comment